Ohioriverutopia: But in judging her as either saint or sinner, aren't we giving way to the false moral dichotomy the whole series critiques? Aren't we to believe that it is a false construct to simply divide the world "into good people and Death Eaters"?

ginevranyx:I don't think the series critiques this.

ginevranyx, I hope you don't mind my suggesting, but it would be interesting as well as helpful to the discussion if you could say what you consider the series says about good and evil.