Would you mind if we toned it down and kept it cordial?
What we *see* in the books is the failure to apply it to a Muggleborn
Remind me - where?
and its application to a half-blood.
Who was living with Muggles at the time, which reinforces the point: the law itself applies to Muggleborns; and Harry was an odd exception because he was living with Muggles - not the norm in the WW at all.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2008-07-01 09:42 pm (UTC)Would you mind if we toned it down and kept it cordial?
What we *see* in the books is the failure to apply it to a Muggleborn
Remind me - where?
and its application to a half-blood.
Who was living with Muggles at the time, which reinforces the point: the law itself applies to Muggleborns; and Harry was an odd exception because he was living with Muggles - not the norm in the WW at all.