You are right (quite horrifyingly so) about Dumbledore's betrayals - and also about Severus keeping silence about Lupin. I wish we could be sure that this last wasn't an example of Rowling's incoherent writing, however! If you really think about it, it's still more "proof" of the theory that CMWinters and I came up with independently of each other - that Severus was "Dumbledore's man" all along (though we both gave him his own motives), and never supported Voldemort at all. This reading still makes more sense of most of the "facts" in the text than the reading Rowling actually gave us. ;) (In my case, I was inspired by the theories of Jodel at the Red Hen website and of Swythyv.)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-08-06 02:44 pm (UTC)(In my case, I was inspired by the theories of Jodel at the Red Hen website and of Swythyv.)